Quality Gate Checklist — 92/100
Copy this file into your plan for every scored post. Tick each box in order. A post with no recorded score has not passed.
Post: (title / topic) Platform(s): (list each version separately — one checklist per platform version) Date checked: (date) Checker: (name — the checker re-opens sources and links itself)
The bar
- Score is 92/100 or higher AND every critical gate passed
- Score recorded below with per-gate points
Scored gates (100 points)
| Gate | Points (max) | Scored |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy / evidence | 20 | /20 |
| Practical usefulness | 15 | /15 |
| Prompt / workflow completeness | 15 | /15 |
| Tool research / links | 10 | /10 |
| Hook / storytelling | 10 | /10 |
| Originality | 10 | /10 |
| Visual / audio | 10 | /10 |
| Platform-native structure | 5 | /5 |
| SEO / accessibility | 5 | /5 |
| Total | 100 | /100 |
Note: 92/100 is a house threshold chosen by the author as a deliberately strict bar. It is not a proven predictor of reach, engagement, or sales.
Critical failures (any one = REVISE or REJECT, regardless of score)
- No unverified factual claim, fabricated tool feature, fake ranking, fake test, or misleading "best" claim
- No broken, unsafe, unofficial, or wrong-destination tool link; no unverified price or free-tier promise
- Exact prompt/steps present wherever a workflow is taught
- No copied creator work, reused clips without meaningful original contribution, or unclear rights
- No misleading income/viral/monetisation guarantee; no inaccurate platform-policy claim
- Required AI disclosure (or other platform disclosure) present where applicable
- No unreadable mobile text, deceptive thumbnail, fake product UI, or major production defect
- No identical mass-produced copy across platforms without native adaptation
Pre-delivery checklist
- Claim ledger present; every claim has source URL + date + confidence; no UNVERIFIED figure stated as fact
- Every tool link opened (or re-checked) and lands on the official destination
- Prompt block complete (8 parts) wherever a workflow is taught
- Hands-on vs desk-researched label present and true
- "Last checked" date present
- Hook passes the 4 S's — Subject / Stakes / Speed / Clarity — and sits in the first line
- One CTA per platform version; no triple-ask closer
- Specificity floor: ≥1 number + ≥1 named entity + ≥1 concrete detail per 100 words
- No AI-tell phrases; em-dash ≤1 per 100 words; no emoji walls
- Character limits respected: X ≤280 weighted per post (Premium ≤25,000) · Threads ≤500 · IG caption ≤2,200 · Pinterest title ≤100, description ≤800 · LinkedIn ≤3,000 · Facebook: no published limit, check the composer
- X native thread (first post no link, ends with a thread marker; link in the reply). Threads link in first reply only + native topic tag
- Hashtags: IG ≤5, LinkedIn 0–1, others 1–3 where they help
- Visual checklist passed: full text scan done, mobile-readable, no fake UI, card and image agree, alt text / captions present
- AI disclosure checked; no income/viral guarantee; no fake ranking or "best" claim
Verdict
- PASS — score ≥92 and zero critical failures
- REVISE — reason: (what must change, which gate)
- REJECT — reason: (why it cannot be fixed as written)
Signature / date: _______________