Worked example — filled-in visual brief + before/after layout
Both examples below are illustrative, written for this skill. They describe a fictional listicle post. No real product, brand, or performance figure is involved.
Filled-in visual brief (Pattern A — listicle / ranking)
- Theme name: "Five quiet tools" — one accent colour per slide, same dark ground.
- Layout sketch (slide by slide):
- Slide 1 (cover): headline "5 tools that save an hour a day" top third, large; one focal image (a desk with a laptop showing a real tool dashboard) bottom two-thirds.
- Slide 2 (second hook): "The one most people skip is #4." centred, with a small arrow cue pointing right.
- Slides 3–7 (one tool each): ranking badge top-left, tool name, "best for" line, one-line benefit, one-line limitation, "find it here" cue at the foot.
- Slide 8 (recap): all five names in one column, one line each, plus the single next action: "Try #4 first."
- Palette balance: dark ground dominates; cream for headline and body; yellow used once per slide only — on the ranking badge on item slides, on the count on the cover.
- Headline text (verbatim): "5 tools that save an hour a day"
- Proof element: real screenshots of each tool's main screen, cropped to the feature being ranked — no mockups, no stock dashboards.
- Text density check: cover 8 words; item slides 28–34 words each; smallest text 30 px (the "find it here" cue).
- Dimensions: 1080 x 1350, 8 slides.
- Alt text: "Carousel ranking five tools that save an hour a day, with a real screenshot and one benefit and one limitation per tool."
Gate result for this brief (illustrative): 15/15 PASS — hook readable in under 2 seconds at phone size; all five ranking cards carry badge, name, best-for, benefit, limitation, and find-it cue; contrast checked (cream on dark ground, yellow badge on dark ground); no ghost words found on the full-size scan.
Before / after layout example (same slide, same words)
The slide: item #4 of the listicle — the tool's name, its best-for line, its benefit, its limitation, and the find-it cue.
BEFORE (fails the gate):
- Headline, tool name, benefit, limitation, and cue all stacked in one centred column on a flat dark field, with a small "TRY IT" button shape at the bottom.
- The tool's real screenshot is absent; a generic laptop stock photo sits behind the text at low opacity.
- The limitation is set in 22 px grey text — unreadable at phone size.
- Fails gate points 2 (no visual story, no proof), 3 (no real subject), 7 (text too small to scan), and 15 (identical layout to the previous three item slides).
AFTER (passes the gate):
- Ranking badge "4" large in the top-left corner, in the accent colour.
- Tool name as the headline, top third, left-aligned; the real screenshot of the tool's main screen fills the middle band, with the benefit as a one-line caption beneath it.
- Best-for line and limitation sit side by side at the foot in 34 px cream text — the limitation is honest and legible, not hidden.
- The find-it cue is a plain text line, not a button shape; the flat-field-plus-button construction is gone.
- The accent balance differs from slides 3, 5, 6, and 7 (badge position and screenshot crop change), so the slide is recognisable as its own item, not a copy.
- Passes the gate 15/15: hook, story, information, proof, hierarchy, and brand are all present; every word was read against the brief in the full text scan.