Top 5 Rankings
Produce Top 5 tool rankings that earn their order: explicit criteria, verified evidence per tool, a stated method, and an honest hands-on vs desk-researched label.
What it is
A method for ranked tool comparisons: seven fixed weighted criteria (task performance 30%, ease of use 15%, value 15%, features 15%, reliability 10%, privacy 10%, availability 5%), a research checklist per tool, hands-on and desk-research protocols, an inline claim ledger, and a score table the reader can check. Desk-researched rankings cap task-performance scores at 7/10 and say so on the asset.
Who it is for
Anyone writing "best X for Y" posts, tool roundups, or comparison carousels who wants the ranking to survive a skeptical reader checking the claims.
Install
Copy this folder into your skills directory as top5-rankings/.
No dependencies.
How to use
- Fix one task and one input for every tool.
- Build the claim ledger first (
references/template.md) — no claim reaches the post without a ledger row. - Research each tool against the checklist; verify prices on the official pages on the day you publish.
- Score 0–10 per criterion, total /100, publish the score table.
- Label the asset "Hands-on tested — [date]" or "Desk-researched — last checked [DATE]. No hands-on test yet."
Example
SKILL.md contains a complete worked example: five AI image
generators scored 0–10 across all seven criteria, totalled /100, with
a "best for" line each — desk-researched, dated 16 November 2026, with
prices verified that day. references/template.md is the blank
research template for the next ranking.
License
MIT. See SKILL.md frontmatter.
Disclaimer
The weights are the author's method, not a researched fact, and desk-researched scores are estimates, not measurements. Prices and free-tier limits change frequently — a ranking is only as current as its "last checked" date.
Example images — real output
The full 8-slide "5 Free AI Tools, Ranked" Instagram carousel this skill produced, published live on 16 Nov 2026 (Instagram post), plus the Pinterest version. Scores shown are the skill's own verified scores (Perplexity 83.5, NotebookLM 80, ChatGPT 78, Gemini 77.5, Claude 77).
Cover — 5 Free AI Tools, Ranked
Files: examples/images/ig-top5-s1-1080x1350.png … ig-top5-s8-1080x1350.png (8 slides, 1080×1350) and examples/images/pin-top5-1000x1500.png (Pinterest, 1000×1500).